Electron discharge device



June 13, 11950 R. ADLER 2,511,143

' ELECTRON DISCHARGE DEVICE Filed Feb. 12, 1948 I s Sheets-Sheet 2 outpui voli'uge input frequency ROBERT ADLER JNVENTOR.

HIS AGE/V7 June 13, 1950 R. ADLER 5 L ELECTRON DISCHARGE DEVIQE Filed Feb. 12, 1948 3 Sheets-Sheet 3 ROBERT LER IN NTOR.

Patented June 13, 195G 2,5ll,l43

2,511,143 ELECTRON DISCHARGE DEVICE Robert Adler, Ghicago; Ill.,;.assignor -.to: Zenith Radio Gcrporation, a corporation of Illinois Application' February 12, IQSfSeriaINOI -ESGQL 15 Claims. (01250-455) perhaps the best knownare circuits-employed:

in the reception of frequency modulated' si'gnals, lthere arises the need-for a device having limiting properties. I A.limiter'may be definedas :a? deivice capable of clipping the-peaks ofan "alternating voltage" wave fed. into it'so ithat'atits output -thereexists.aniialternating" voltage of substan- -.tially constant amplitude whenever therinput signal exceeds a predetermined minimuma leyelr It' is, Lfurthermore; desirable in 'manytapplica- :tions,11iincludingsireceivers for "frequency cmodudated signals, that the process of limiting be carried :out instantaneously. i As'iinstantaneous :lirn- -1itermay.bedefinedas aidevicetcapable:of retain- J'ng' itslimiting" propertiessiindependently of @the speedi-with which-the amplitudeiof the; input'sig- "113.1 varies.

Devices are known in the prior art, sucha-as, Toriiistanca-circuits including at least'two bi'ased ire'ctifiers, -whichvmeet the requirements stated. These :devices," however, have the disadvantage "of bein zrather complex and requiring anlarge number of circuit components.

vzItis aiprimary object .of the invention to; provideam-electron discharge device havingximproved inherent limiting characteristics.

A vacuum tube constructed.- in' :sucha-rmanner that the-plate current remains zero overra wide range of grid'voltages, then rapidly rises -to= a definite-intensity withina-narrow range ofigrid voltage change, andfinally remains-constant-at that definite intensity over a-second widerange of grid voltages, wouldbe capableof meeting the requirements above stated. -Itis-a further object toprovide a vacuum tubeof such construction.

In the reception oifrequency modulated rad-i -signa1s,-it-is necessary toprovidemeans for con- :verting the frequency, variations of the received signals to amplitude variations :--which -may be :used to drive a loudspeaker orother suitable reproduction device. Such means of demodulating the input signals may be arbitrarilyiclassified into two categories; namely, discriminators em- ;ployinga pair 'ofibalanced diodes, and" discriminators "employing :a": pair of control: grids-arranged in cascade. In the past, discriminators ofthe latter type' have "found 'very limited application, since amplitude variations in-:the input signals arexnot suficiently eliminated-Thy a conventional. mixeror converter tube. "When used following a1imiter,'suchdiscriminators"ofier no substantial advantage over"'thei'double;idlode type, Theidouble diode discriminator', however, requires a separate limiter stage, afliscriminator transformer, a pair offdiodes and the'Jassocia-ted resistance' capacitance load networks, -fand other \J circuit elementsrexternal L ether tubes; iiAiconsidera'ble economy of componentarpartspmight :be eifectedif the limiter-and disoriminatortstages oould ibe-combined. 1: lt-zis-ianuimportant objectlof Lthis invention ltosprovideian electron idischarge :devicawhichais:suitablerforjuse as aeeombination .limiter-discriminaton in connection withaw-frequency modulationradio receiver.

. :Itis a further-obj ect ofv the inventionvto -cprovide an electron discharge .-device--.of the electron ,beamtypaemploying a pair 011 601113101; grids; ar-

ranged-in cascaderwhich. combines, the functions or} an amplitude limiter: and a -irequency de modulator.

Still another object or thezinvention-is to; effect ,a; considerable economy, oi. partsby-combining the limiter. and-discriminatorstages ofwaifre- ,quency ;modu1ationnrad-io receiver, reducing ,the

number of circuit-elements inithetcombined iter-discriminaton- .stage,,-;to-., .at-sin gle tuned {circuit. .Yet anotherl. important object of Lthe invention is to provide, "for. affrequency -modulation (radio ilreo'eiver, such a 'singlellimiteridisdfim inatori stageifwhich obtains audio. output com parable to that, of. a. conventional ldoiiblediod'e phase sensitive"discriminator. The features of the invention which are believedto be novel are-set forthwitn articularity Zintheapp'efided claims. The invention,togther with further objects and advantages thereof, may more readily, ,b'eun'de1"stood, however; by .iererrin i to "theiifollowing descriptiomtakenfin connection with"the accompanying"drawingstin iwhich "like'refer'ence'.numerals"iridicatelike :ele "ments'endin'which; Figure l" is a"schematicrepresentation of-the electrodearrangement-in a device *cons'tructed' in accordancewith theinvention.

*Figu-re 2' is a schematicrepresentationto a simplification of the airrangement of Figure 1 Figure 13 -is-an'-' idealized graphical -representa tion crane anode eurrenvgrid voltage charact'eris'tio ot thedevice-schematically'shown in Fia -ure 2.

Figure 4 is a modification 'of the arrangement of Figure- 2. I

Figure- 5 is a-schematic circuit ldia-giam',- ncorpor'ating the 'd'evice ofiF'igure i, or a circuit 'inoorporating -the device of Fi'gu-re i.

'Fig-ure d is a g-raphic'al represeritation *of an operatingcharacteristic of the -device ot Figure-4.

Figure 7 is a schematic representation of arm: ther modification of the invention.

Figure 8 is i a -gi'aphical"representationor an operating:characteristic?"of? an electron disch'arge deviceconstruetediin accordance withi the sche-i matic'representationroF-Fieure:7.

IFigure ll is argraphica1:representation of tcer' i i There are tubes known in mm voltage and current relationships in a device such as that shown in Figure 7.

Figure is a schematic circuit diagram, incorporating the device of Figure 7, of a combined limiter-discriminator stage of a frequency modulation radio receiver.

Figure 11 is the discriminator characteristic of the circuit shown schematically in Figure 10.

Figure 12 is an exploded perspective view, partly in section, of a physical embodiment of the invention.

Figure 13 is a transverse section taken at I3--l3 of Figure 12.

It is to be understood throughout the specification and claims that, in all cases, the tube electrodes must be arranged within an evacuated envelope.

the prior art in which a control grid is preceded in the electron path by a positive electrode, commonly referred to as a screen in converter tubes and as a space charge grid in some other tubes. In these tubes, the control grid following the positive electrode has characteristics which include a wide region of zero plate current and a wide region of constant plate current. In the intervening region, however, the plate current rises rather gradually,

and several volts of grid voltage change are 'required to change the plate current from zero to its full intensity. The rise of plate current with grid voltage becomes even more gradual as the limiting intensity is approached, whereas an abrupt change from the full slope to the zero slope prevailing in the region of constant current is most desirable for limiting.

It has been found that it is possible to obtain the desired characteristic, consisting of a region of zero plate current separated from a region of constant current by a narrow region of high transconductance, by means of a novel tube structure. The basic configuration required is illustrated in Figure 1. I

An electron gun 20, comprising a cathode 2|, 9, directing member 22, and an accelerator 23, projects a beam of electrons upon a control grid 24 through a narrow aperture 25 in an accelerating electrode 26. An additional electrode or anode 28, responsive to an applied unidirectional operating potential for producing a unidirectional electrostatic accelerating field adjacent control grid 24 on the side thereof remote from cathode 2|, is provided. The accelerating electrode 26 is operated at a positive potential at or near the anode operating potential, while the control grid 24 is operated at cathode potential, or, preferably, biased slightly negative with respect to the oathode 2I. There is also provided a lens electrode 21 for adjusting the degree of convergence or divergence of the electron beam as it leaves the aperture 25 in the accelerating electrode 26. Preferably, the dimensions of the electrodes in a'direction perpendicular to the plane of the drawing are made large relative to the width of the cathode emitting surface; with such an arrangement, a sheet-like electron beam of rectangular cross-section is produced, and large values of beam current may be obtained with relatively low operating voltages.

It has been found, in accordance with the invention, that whenever the distance from the aperture 25 to the control grid 24 is large compared to the width of the aperture 25 itself, it is possible to adjust, for any given beam current, the potentials on the lens electrode 21 and on the accelerating electrode 26 in such a manner that unusually high transconductance is obtained over a narrow range of voltages applied to control grid 24, while at more negative voltages the 5 anode current remains zero and at more positive voltages it remains constant. It is especially important that the rise of the plate current remains rapid up to the immediate vicinity of that grid voltage at which the anode current becomes constant.

It is known in the prior art that improved transconductance is obtained in a control grid preceded by a positive electrode if the electrons are so directed that they arrive at the control grid with substantially perpendicular incidence. On the other hand it has been found desirable to reduce the number of electrons which, after having been rejected by the control grid, return through the positive electrode to the vicinity of the cathode whence they originated. For this purpose, means for deflecting the electrons, such .as rods positioned in the interelectrodespace or forming part of the control grid, are commonly used. The requirements .of sufficient deflection of returning electrons and of perpendicular incidence of passing electronsare, however, mutually contradictory in tubes built according to the prior art.

By making the electronspace current emerge from an aperture which is narrow compared to the distance between that aperture and the control grid, it has been made possible for both requirements to be met simultaneously. More specifically, it is believed that the process which takes place in the space between the aperture and the control grid 24 may be described as follows. I

The effective potential in a plane immediately adjacent the control grid 24 may be represented in a, well-known manner by the potential of the control grid plus a fraction of the potential of the positive electrode following the control grid. If this effective potential is slightly positive, and if the configuration and the potential of the lens electrode 21 are so adjusted that the trajectories 'of electrons leaving the aperture are substantially parallel, a minimum positive potential can be found which, when applied to the accelerating electrode 26, renders positive the potential everywhere within the beam between the accelerating electrode and the control grid, so that all of the electrons pass through the grid. Under these circumstances, the beam remains narrow throughout the space from the aperture to the control grid. If, on the other hand, control grid 24 is made sufliciently negative to render the effective potential zero or slightly negative, electrons can no longer pass the potential barrier so established, and all electrons turn about. Because every electron now traverses twice the space between the accelerating electrode 26 and the control grid 24, the space charge existing between these two electrodes is doubled, and a divergent electrostatic field is set up in this space. The electron trajectories which were originally substantially parallel are now bent away from the center of the beam, with the result that most of the returning electrons strike the solid parts of accelerating electrode 26 rather than passing through the aperture 25 on their return trip.

Thus, it is possible to have electron trajectories which intersect the control grid substantially at right angles as'long as all of the beam is passed. This makes it possible to pass the entire beam even at, a very low effective potential ina seam-iris 5 plaiie adjacent thetontrm grid. noweverronce t e 1 grid potential"becomesnegative "enoughto stop"a substantial number of the eletronsythe resulting increase inspace charge bends the trajectories and thereby reduces "cumulatively that number of the electrons which can still .pa'ss through the grid, whileatthe sametime deflectirlg the returning electronsa'wayirom the aperture.

fThe" structure shown in Figure 1 represents; a ne'xime arrangement on'which'the properties; "of devicsbuilt according to this'invention niayconveniently be studied. It is more." economical, Thewever, Y so to construct the' deviceslthat certain elements perform""du'al functions. More specifically, it is desirable to combinethe accelerator 23 of the electron -gunifl with the accelerating "el'ectrodelfi andtobmitthelensielectrode 21. "*If'theposi'tionpf the electron gun is-"properly chosen with reference to the'width' of aperture 25 and thespacingbetwe'enthat aperture and con- -troigrid 24, it becomes possible'to operate electrodes 23 and 26 at acommon positiive potential. "Furthermore, omission 'of'the lens electrode 21 7 makes it necessary so to -constructi'the electron gun?!) that the electrontrajectories"at the point where-the electron beam leaves the aperture 25 'aresubstantially parallel. A structure which fulfills these conditions is'shown schematically in *Figlirefl.

*In Figure 2, aplurality of electrodes are arf'ranged in' substantially symmetrical relation, with 'iespect to a reference plane 'R,such electrodes including in the "order named, a cathode 30, an acceleratingelectrode 3|, a control-grid. 32,and arianode33. -'A beam forming ordirec'tingplate 34, constructed of electrically conductive material, is arranged to surroundthe cathode 30 inf-such a way that electrons emittedby. the-cathode are formed 'into a,"convergent"beam. Accelerating electrode 3 "is-provided with a centrally located aperturepr slot 35"which' registers with the electronbeam, so that apositive potential app'earing onelectrode 3 [results in "an'accelerating field between slot 35 andbathode 30. v outwardly extending portions '36 may beiprovided on each side of slot '35 to'adjust the refractive powerof slot 35 it is preferred that "portion I36 extend parallel to the axis and toward" the cathode .30, 'inorder to insure that theelectrons emitted from the cathode" 30 are 'formed" into" a substantially "parallel beam in the regionbetw'een electrodes 3| s an. V

Focusing 'meanss'l; such asa pair of rods or a member having aslot','preferably are inserted between the accelerating' electrode 3| and; the grid 32. Focusing means '31 insure that all the elec- 'trons'emerging from-slot35' are-directed to; the giid'32. 'In operation,"-it'is preferredj'in order tom'inimize the number of "externalconnections; to connect focusing means 3T:directly;-;to;-the 'cathode'35. The'anode current Ib grid-voltage E" characteristics of a tube such as that shown and described in 'connection with Figureg2 are shown in idealizedform in Figure 3. These "characteristicsare ofthe step function 'type,- in which a wide region 4| of constant anode .current operation'is' separated from a' region 42 of ="zero' anode current operation "by' a'narrow region 33 of high 'trans'conducta'nce; region43 occurring atf-increasingly negative values ofgrid voltage with increasing 'anodeoperati'ng voltage "Eb.

While a tube cbnstructed as"showni-and *described in connection with-Figures :1 and-32mm- "-vids inherent'limitifig characteristicsfthe inter-f 1 f desirably high'; and the internal anode resistance f' isj'undesir'ably' low, 'for' some practical applications. "There"is*shown"inFigure 4 a'schematic 5 representation "of a tube not only 'embodying"the advantages ofthestructures"of Figures 1 and :2,

butalso having anode characteristics =approa'chingthose "of a beam power tube 'or' pe'ntode.

ti'briof that shown and described in connection Figure' 2f'theanode 33 of Figure 2*being replaced by a second accelerating electrode50 fol- ."lowed bysecondfdciising means 5| and an anode 52. '"In thi'sembodiment, thesecond accelerating e ctrode50,' constituting the "additional electrode responsive "to" an applied unidirectional operating i pot'ential for "producing a unidirectional a'c- "celeratingelectrostatic field adjacent control "grid 32,-is provided with aslot or aperture 53 which registers with the electron beam projected through" the grid '32. Extending 1 portions '54, ex-

tending on each' sideof'slot'53toward the" control *gneez, are providedto produce-the desireclfield configuration. In seamen, the contour of first focusing means 31' is adaptedin' a'preferred'way "*to" insure "substantially perpendicular incidence ofthe electrofi beam-on thecontro'l grid'32. To "this end also, additional'extending portions '55 are provided on each sideof slot 35, such'additional portions being directed" toward the -grid ln operationj' a device constructed in accordance "with Figure "4"is""dis'tinguished by an operating characteristic similar-to a s'ingle' curve of 35 Figure 3', the lower limit of the" "constant-current region lfb'ing determined by the operating :po tentials of the accelerating electrodes "3 and -50 and the anode "52. "In practice, it is preferred'to operate theaccelerating"electrodes 3| andiflat a comnion""'positivepotential; at 'ornear the potential at'the anode" 52 i although" such operation" is not" essential. Furthermore; in order to minimize the number of external connections of "the" device, it is preferred to connect internally *the :directing member 34 *"andfocusing means 31 and 5| to the "cathode.

I A practical circuit incorporating the device-of 'Fig'urefl i'ssho'wninFigure 5. The "circuit is pro- :vided with an input terminal 60 and" an output vided for both input circuitand output circuit. 'Input "signals are applied to'the control grid32 *by' means of input'termin'als 60 and a 'Suitable operating bias is'su'pplied'by means of a cathode biasresistance 63*and associa'ted bypass capa'citance it connected" between the cathode 30 and "the commonterminal 6|. The acceleratingelectrodes 3| and 50' are connected together and to 'the-positive"terminal of a suitable source of unidirectional operating potential, such source being here shown as abattery 65, the negative terminal of whichisco'nn'ected tothe common terminal 6|. Theanod'e 52 is connected to the positive terminal of battery 65 "through a suitable load impedance 65 Zb. "iOutputis'obtained between theoutput terr'ninals62, connected to anode '52, andthe common *ter'minalGI. V

'A system as-shown in Figure 5 is'characterized by--an-oper'atingcurve such 'as'that shown in 7oFigure 6. -In'other words, whenever the input signal exceeds a, certaincritical minimumamplitude Eio,ja|n output signal of substantially constant'amplitude is obtained. I p

Referring'again to Figure 5 i t is po ssible to 15 obtain output voltages of various waveforms from anode circuits.

ii 135E115 1.48

.a sinusoidal input, the waveform of the output I voltage depending on the nature of the load impedance Zb'; By'making Zb a tuned circuit -.'resonating at a suitable frequency, a sinusoidal output at the input. frequency or one of its harmonics may be. obtained; for example, an

harmonic generator constructed in this manner is disclosed and claimed in the copending application of Robert Adler, Serial No. 118,074, filed .September 27, 1949, for Harmonic generators,

and assigned to the present assignee. A resistive load Zb results in a square wave output. A triangular wave is obtained'if Zb is capacitive, and,

;;by makingZb inductive, a series of sharp impulses of alternating polarity is produced. The output appearing'between terminals 62 and 6|,

7 however, is always substantially constant, both in amplitude and waveform, so long as the input signal exceeds the critical amplitude E10. Thus,

the circuit of Figure may be adapted to many applications, such as, for example, a limiter in a frequency modulation radio receiver.

A device constructed in. accordance with the schematic representation of Figure 4 provides an exceptionally wide region of constant anode current operation and is especially adapted as a limiter; furthermore, such limiting is accomplished instantaneously, without the time constants associated with circuits using ordinary pentodes or beam power tubes.

In a receiver for frequency modulated signals, such instantaneous limiting results in a decreased tendency to pick up ignition noise or similar extraneous disturbances.

As an additional advantage, the use of an accelerating electrode in place of a screen grid results in a decrease in that portion of the fluctuation noise caused by the random variation of the division of space current between the screen and This property, in connection with the high ratio of transconductance to anode "current attained in devices constructed according to this invention, makes tubes of the type shown in Fig. 4 particularly suitable for amplifiers oper- T 'ating at extremely low input voltage levels where signal-to-noise ratio is an important consideration.

. As a further embodiment of the invention, it

If possible to construct an electron discharge 'device, for use in a frequency modulation radio re'civer, which combines in a single electron stream the functions of amplitude limiter and a frequency demodulator of the type hereinafter referred to as a space charge discriminator.

The space charge discriminator, as such,'is dis- Y closed and claimed as to its broader aspects in U .8. Patent Number 2,208,091 to Zakarias. U. S. Patent Number 2,233,706 to Kalmus teaches the incorporation in the circuit of Zakarias of the function of amplitude limiting by the proper selection of self-biasing circuit elements;

In practice, it has been found that the circuits of Zakarias and Kalmus are subjectto undesirable restrictions imposed by the limitations of the presently available discharge devices.

In the first place, the system described-by Zakarias must follow an amplitude limiting system in order to realize optimum operating conditions. While the circuit of Kalmus combines the limiting anddemodulating functions,

the limiting accomplished by such a circuit is satisfactory over only 'a narrow range of input signal amplitudes. -Furthermore, instantaneous limiting can not bebbtained with a circuit of of the type shown and described in connection with Figure 2. Such: a tube isshown schematically in'Figure' 'h i The device of Figure-7 is similar in'its structural features to .that of Figure 4. A second control grid -10,2hereinafter referred to as the u'uadrature grid, is disposed between second focusing means 5| and the anode 52.

In addition, focusing element 5| is extended also to function as electrostatic shield between the input grid 32 and the quadrature grid 78, thereby to minimize the intergrid capacity. In all other respects, the structure represented by Figure 7 is identical to that shown and described in con- 25.

nection withFigured.

' In the device of Figure 7,. the input grid 32 hasassociated therewith a'characteristic resembling a step function,-:with a region of constant current'separated from', azero current region by a narrow region of high transconductance, as shown in Figurev 3. By suitably spacing and arranging the electrodes, the constant current region-may bemadeqto commence at an inpu grid voltage having a negative value.

Since the felectron stream passes through the first grid in the form, of a concentrated beam, it

- may be'di'rected througha second system, comprising the second slot 53 and the second grid 10, similar to theifirst-system comprising the first slot and the firstgrid 32. The second grid Ill has'acharacteristic similar to that of the first grid 32, provided that the first grid is operated within the constantcurrent region.

An idealized representation of the anode current Ib-input grid voltage E01 characteristic of a tube constructed in accordance with Figure l is shown in: Figure 8., It is seen that the anode current Ib. remains: constant for all values of voltage E132 appearing, on the second grid in ex- *c'es's-of aicritical .voltage Ea As thevoltage on the second: grid is-Tm'ade more negative, assuming that the first gridal'ways operates in the constant current region, the anode current decreases. For

example, when the quadrature grid voltage E02 is equal to zero,-.-the operating characteristic is indicated by the-curve labeled Ec2=0 and for some single arbitrary negative value of quadrature grid voltage, the anode operating characteristic is represented by the curve labeled Ecz 0. Thus, whenever, the instantaneous voltage on the first grid is greater than E 1 and the instantaneous "voltage on the second grid is greater than o'r 'equalto E2, the instantaneous anode current remains constant.

It has beenseen that the tube comprises a pair of control' grids 32and 10 arranged in cascade. These gridszmay be compared with a pair of interrupterswitches,,the passage of current to the anode 52 being dependent on both switches being-closed. An input signal applied to the first grid 32-resultswina substantially square wave space current within the tube, the conducting and non-conducting periods being equal in length. -If asignal'of the same frequency is ap- Jl plied toi-thesecondz-grid l0, space;current fiows e aurin sr d wh e-t e.- s al p bothgrids}, aresimultaneously positive. If the signal appliedZto. the-second grid fillis shifted 90 degrees with respect-to the signal applied to the first ;g rid 32, anode current flows during onequarter of the. cycle, whilezno anode current fiows.

during theremainingthree-quarters of the cycle. The average anode current therefore is onefourth the instantaneous value-of space current. Variation of-the phase displacement between the Qutheinput.grid is. approximately straight and,

two signals-produces corresponding'variations in the le ngth of the conductivaperiods, and therefore, in the average anode current. Such a characteristicds exactly-whatis desired for av combinedlimiter-discriminator stage in a frequency modulation radio receiver.

The switching action may bemore fully understoodbyreferring tqFigure 9, in which cer symmetrical. With this assumptiomthe area oi, the trapezoid; bounded by the anode; current curve. is notchanged by the transitionpfrom. the steep slopeto themoregradual slope. Therefore the, average anode currentwIb .remainsunchanged;

tain. relevant voltage; an d current relationships are graphically depicted. In this figure, condi tions are illustrated for the case in-vv hich the volta esapplied to the quadrature grid lags exactly- BQ; degrees behindthe-voltage applied to the ;inp ut grid.- Twoconditions are illustrated, one based ona relatively; large inputsignal voltage-.egl andrtheother based, on a much smaller.

input signal voltage. Cgl'. In order to -si-mpliiy the explanation, sinusoidal Waveforms, and a constant signal-e g on the quadrature grid,; are ss m d;

That interval .;during,,whi ch the signals applied to both grids aresignultaneously positive, so en.- abling the, space current v to reach the anode, extends approximatelyifrom-the instant denoted as -the the in ut-signal amplitude .is varied, pro, videdonly that the inputsignal amplitude is; sufiiciently greater than the limiting level 1 p0 1. tential E; that the entire spacev current reaches 2Q;;;the anode, for, at least aportion of. the cycle,

bylthephase aneler f .0? o ha en e rb 80"- More accurately, anodecurrentstarts to flow at thejtime corresponding;-to the vertical line 80, whenthe voltagee z on, the r quadrature grid be comesgmorepositive than its cut-olfpotential Egz the anode current reaches its fulll intensity at the time: corresponding .to the vertical line 8| when the quadrature grid, its 4 voltage, still rising; attains the limiting level potential :Ea, During the. period of rising anode current between times; I,

' 1 45, cuit. in which "case no separate circuitelementr,

80-and 8 l, thepotentialof the first grid-is greater than the potential E1required-sfor'limiting; thus operation-in the region; of constant current is as:

There isishownr in. ,Figure :10, aschematic circuit diagram of-a combined.amplitudeflimiter. andspace charge discriminator which utilizes a ,tubea, constructed in accordance with Figure -7. In-

thesoutput of-the: customary intermediate frea. quency amplifier (not shown) by way of input terminals..90 and-9!. Suitable constant oper. ating; bias, voltage is supplied+by means on acathode bias resistance 92 v andz associated=bypass y,

capacitance 93 arrangeddn circuit with-thecathode- 30-in the customary manner? The. acceler ating electrodes 3l and-5U are interconnected, either internally or'externally, and connectedto 'thepositive terminal of a suitable source: of-

positive unidirectional operating potential, here shown as a battery -94; the negative terminal: of:- which source being connected to terminal-.9l.- A parallel resonant circuit 95,- comprising-- an inductance 96 and a capacitance 91., is connected-1 between the second" grid" 10 and terminal- 9h It is to be :understoodrthat capacitance I 91 -may-; comprise the-distributed"capacitance of -theecir-e "fll'appearsc- Audio frequency output-voltage is.

surecL-and 'thelanode currentld ting this periodis not. afiected bythe potential at the input gglid. If an-input signal egl, which isllarge in comparison- =with; .Er, is applied to the. input-- grid, the anode current'ib'. continuesqto;flow with its-fu1l SIS-and II!!! are bypassed--for the intermediate intensity. until the time, marked b the vertical;

line 8Z, that the input grid, its. voltaggdecreass,- becomes, more. ne at ve. than e im ingg level potential Er. At :this I time. the anode; cur-v rentlibxbegins to drop ,andreaches,zero, at the; time, markedby .line. 83,, that; the input grid reaches CutOfii' jEgl. It then ,remains,zero until approximately. three quarters ofa cycle later,

the A entire sequence is repeated It, now, the signal applied to the input grid is ecr e a smalle mpl t e st. il".

stant; anode currentno, longer flows until the time corresponding to line-B2, but l the anode cunrerlt ief begins to dropgat the earliertime, corresponding .to line 84. On the. other .hand, the. decrease in anode currentaoccurs much more, slowly and; zero anode s current not I reached until. thegtime corresponding to line I I 85,. considerably. later than, it was .reached in the. ,case

of larger iinputjsignal amplitude.-

The instantaneous ;variation: of the .anode tourrent withrespect .tq;tir ne. is, plotted in the lower,

P ttiilfi JQI; hem n t:- eig ls a l de r5 derived froman anode load. resistance 98 con nected between the anode 52 and-the-positive terminal=ofvsource Mby -means of-a pair-of? output terminals 99 and" H30; Output'terminals' frequency by a capacitance "II.-

In operation, theparallel resonant circuit =95 is tuned to resonate at the intermediate frequency. As is-taught byZakar-is, a unilateral space charge coupling-exists from'the input gr-id 32" to the quadrature grid 1!]; That "isto say, voltage is induced on the second-grid =10 aby the space current passed by the first'grid -32r how,-

ever; the potential of the first grid 32 is unaffectedby thepotential variation ofeth'e. sec-.-

0nd grid 10.. This, space charge coupling between. grids .is equivalent phasewise'to a one-.1 way negative. capacitance; consequently, the, voltageinducedon the second grid llblagsthe voltage of thefirstgrid 32 by exactly degrees wheneverthe input voltage varies at exactly the frequency. to. which. the resonant circuit =1isy tuned. Frequency. deviation of, the input voltage applied to gridv 32 results in a change in the phase displacement between the voltages appearingzon 'ixfirst andmsecondlgrids 32. and 10,,andthus in, y aeean decurr n ar l he ut- 9 se pmerinaa ross er inals... I. nd .1 I lill ,.vari,es in arnplitude in accordance with. the

aura-14s frequency variation of the input signal applied because of the relations explained in connec tionwith Fig. 9. The response to amplitude variations of the input signal is further reduced by the substantially constant amplitude of the quadrature signal, which develops on grid as a consequence of unilateral space charge coupling from the input grid 32, for all input signal voltages exceeding a certain minimum. This stability of the quadrature voltage results from the fact that the space charge which develops in the vicinity of grid 10 is a function of the space current, and that ina tube constructed according to this invention the space current varies between. zero and a constant intensity.

The demodulator characteristic for the circuit shown and described in connection with Figure 10 is shown in Figure 11 as curve H0. The demodulator characteristic for the welle known combination of an amplitude limiter and a conventional double-diode phase sensitive discriminator is shown as the dotted curve II I, the coordinate axes of curve Ill having been displaced for the purpose of facilitating comparif son between the two systems. The outputof the limiter-discriminator of Figure 10 is similar to that of the conventional double-diode discriminator within the linear region. although the characteristic peaks of curve H0 are less pronounced than in the case of the conventional double-diode discriminator. cuit shown in Figure 10 provided a wider linear region of operation than the conventional phase sensitive discriminator circuit, thus permitting improved tuning and greater output.

There is shown in Figure 12 a perspective view, partly in section, of a combination limiter-discriminator tube constructed in accordance with the arrangement shown and described in con-- It is to be noted that the 0170- nection with Figure'l. The electrodes are supported between a pair of mica tube mounts I20 and I 2| within an evacuated envelope I22, the customary getter I23 being provided for absorbing any residual gas' after evacuation. The

electrodes are brought out through a sealed base I24 to respective terminals or pins I25.

Figure 13 is a transverse section taken at I 3l3 of the tube of Figure 12, and is included in order to show more completely the structure of such a tube. i

Merely by way of illustration, and in no sense by way of limitation, it has been found that the following dimensions may be used in producing a tube of the type shown and described in connection with Figures 12 and 13.

' Inches All electrodes have a longitudinal dimension of 1% of an inch. All ofv the sheet metal electrodes are constructed of four-mil stock. The input grid 32 is formed by mounting 88 substantially parallel elements :per'inch of l.5 -mil wire on a pair of supporting rods, and the quadrature grid Ill is constructed in a similar manner, using '72 substantially parallel elements per inch of 2-mil wire. Thus, each of the grids 32, 10 comprisesa plurality of substantially coplanar parallel conducting elements disposed across the path of the 1 electron beam to define a plurality of continuous transverse interstices across the entire width of each grid. In. addition, the accelerating electrodes 3| and 50 are internally interconnected as are the cathode 30, the beam forming plate 34,

micromhos per milliampere space current may be obtained, and 3 milliamperes of space current are drawn with an anode operatingpotential of volts.

While there have been shown and described certain present preferred embodiments of the invention, it is to be understood that numerous variations and modifications may be made; and

it is contemplated, in the appended claims,' to

cover all such modifications as fall within the true spirit and scope of the invention.

I claim:

1. An electron discharge device comprisingz'an electron gun including a cathode for projecting a beam of space electrons; a control system comprising an accelerating electrode having an aperture registering with said" beam followed by a control grid including a plurality of conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam at a distance from said accelerating electrode greater than at least one of the transverse dimensions of said aperture; a focusing system, comprising at least a focusing electrode included in said electron gun, for causing said electrons to approach said grid substantially at right angles; and an additional electrode responsive to an applied unidirectional operating potential to produce a unidirectional electrostatic accelerating field adjacent said grid on the side thereof w remote from said electron gun.

2. An electron discharge device comprising: an electron gun including a cathode for projectinga beam of space electrons; a control system comprising an accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having an aperture registering with said beam followed by a control grid including a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam at a distance from said accelerating electrode greater than at least one of the trans-' verse dimensions of said aperture; a focusing system, comprising at least a focusing electrode included in said electron gun, for causing said electrons to approach said grid substantially at right angles; and an additional electrode responsive to an applied unidirectional operating potential to produce. a unidirectional electrostatic accelerating field adjacent said grid on the side thereof remote from said electron gun.

3. An electron discharge device comprising: an electron gun including a cathode for projecting a sheet-like electron beam of substantially rectangular cross-section; a control system com,-

prising an accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having a slot registering with said beam followed by a control grid including a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam at a distance from said. accelerating" electrode- 13:: reat r hanat-le st ne. ofstheltra srerseldims i ns, of a daperturea a:focnsing;. y tem;-: c p i n at. leas a focusing lec rodeiincluded in-1;; said electron gun, for causing theelectronscon-1., stituting said beamtogapproach said grid sub-J, 5; tantially at right an l s; andian additionalele e trode responsive to an applied unidirectional:ope; crating potentialto produce.aiunidirectional;e1 qst ic accelerating field djaQQ fq saidsjgridronz 1 the side thereof remote from saidaelectronrgunvl g 4 electron-dischargedevice comprisingzfan electron; gun including :a cathode for projecting heet-l ke le tron eam of substantially rectan: it la t msswection; a con -rob sys em cqmprisins. an acceIerating; electrode includcdxin asaidlzelec- 1 5. on ps'unrand having a slotiregisterin Withz said r beam followed by acontrolgrid including 3121 .111. rality oi substantially parallel conduoting-.,=elements disposed across thelpathuofgsaidabeameat a; distance from said accelerating; electrodearzm greater than;twice thesmallest. transverse dimen.-.. sion oi said; slot; ate-focusing @system;- comprising 1,- at least a focusing electrode includedlin said e1e.Q--. trongun, forrcausingl the electrons constituting said beam to approach said grid substantially at right angles; and an additionalelec-trode responretaana pli d unid rec ional: pe a nap ie tial to produce a unidirectional accelerating elec: trostatic field adjacent.said grid on the side thereof remote from said electron gun.

5. An electron discharge device comprising: an electron gunincludingta ncathodesfor projecting: a beamnf spaceelectrons; acontrolsystemlcoin-e prisinglan accelerating electrode lincludedfinlsaid electron gun and lhavingansaperture registering- 5;; withisaid beam followedby alcontrol. grid includa ing: a Lplurality of. substantially.- .parallel coplanar conducting elements disposed-across the path of. said beam .at .distance .frorn-:saidaaccelerating electrodegreaterr. than twice theismallestatrans-g 40 verse; dimension .of. saidnslot; a..foousing system comprising at leasta focusinglelectrode included; in said electron gun, for causing said electrons to approach said grid substantially at right angles; and an anode.

6. An electron discharge device comprising: an electron gun including a cathode for projecting a sheet-like electron beam of substantially rectangular cross-section; a control system comprising a first accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having a slot registering with said beam followed by a control grid including a plurality of substantially parallel coplanar conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam at a distance from said accelcrating electrode greater than the smallest transverse dimension of said slot; a focusing system, comprising at least a focusing electrode included in said electron gun, for causing the electrons constituting said beam to approach said grid 0 substantially at right angles; a second accelerating electrode having a slot registering with said beam;and an anode.

'7. An electron discharge device comprising: an electron gun including a cathode for projecting a sheet-like electron beam of substantially rectangular cross-section; a control system comprising an accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having a slot bounded by substantially parallel portions extending toward said cathode and registering with said beam followed by a control grid including a plurality of substantially parallel coplanar conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam to define a plurality of continuous transverse interstices -across;= the ,entire lwidth: ofvsaid grid at' a distance from said-acceleratingzelectrode greater;

than the lsmallest transverse dimension ofsaid slot;- a focusing system comprising at least a focusing velectrode included in said electron gun forlcausing the electron constituting saidbeam to l andcan anode.

8.. An electron discharge device comprising: an

tangularcross-section; a control system com-- electrongun-includinga cathode for projectinga sheet-likeelectron-beam of substantially rec-l prising antaccelerating electrode included in'said' electron-gunand: having a slot registering l with plurality of substantially parallel conducting elelsaid beam followed by. a controlgridinc1udingaments-.tdisposed across the pathof. said beam todefinela plurality :.of continuous transverse intersticesv across thesentire widthv of said gridat a distance from said accelerating electrode greater than twice the smallest transverse dimension of I said slot; a focusing system, comprising at least a focusing; electrode included in said electron gum for.-,causing the electrons constituting said J n les; a'second slotted accelerating electrode; ndr manode.

9.;eIn an electron discharge device of the type zs beamto approachsaid grid substantially at right-- 1-lWhi ;;the; electron: s'pacetcurrentv is confined to abeam: a control system comprising an aperiturned acceleratinglelectrode followed by antintensitygcontrol grid which consists essentially of a plurality; of substantially parallel conducting q elements disposed across the path of said beam at a-qdis ta ice-from said accelerating electrode.

greater than at. least one of the transverse dimensions; ofthe aperture of said accelerating elece trode anda focusing system for causing-the space electrons constituting said beam to approach said grid substantially at right angles.

cross-section: a control system comprising a slotted accelerating electrode followed by an intensity control grid which consists essentially of a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam at a distance from said accelerating electrode greater than the smallest transverse dimension of the slot of said accelerating electrode; and a focusing system for causing the space electrons constituting said beam to approach said grid substantially at right angles.

11. In an electron discharge device of the type in which the electron space current is confined to a beam; a pair of control systems arranged in cascade along the path of said beam, each of said systems comprising an apertured accelerating electrode followed by a control grid which comprises a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across said path at a distance from the accelerating electrode greater than at least one of the transverse dimensions of the aperture of the accelerating electrode.

12. In an electron discharge device of the type in which the electron space current flows in a sheet-like beam of substantially rectangular cross-section: a pair of control systems arranged in cascade along the path of said beam, each of said. systems comprising a slotted accelerating electrode followed by a control grid which comprises a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across said path at a distance from the accelerating electrode greater than the smallest transverse dimension of the slot of the accelerating electrode.

13. An electron discharge device comprising in the order named: an electrongun for projecting an electron beam; a first accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having an aperture registering with said beam; a first control grid spaced from said first accelerating electrode by a distance greater than at least one of the transverse dimensions of said aperture and in--,

Y eluding a plurality of substantially parallel coplanar conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam; a second accelerating electrode having an aperture registering with said beam; a second control grid spaced from said second accelerating electrode by adistance greater than at least one of the transverse dimensions of the aperture of said second accelerating electrode and including a plurality of substantially parallel conducting elements disposed across said path; and an anode.

14. An electron discharge device comprising in the order named: an electron gun for projecting a sheet-like electron beam of substantially rectangular cross-section; a first accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having a slot registering with said beam; a first control grid spaced from said first accelerating electrode by a distance greater than the smallest transverse dimension of said slot and including a plurality sag-511,118 s of substantially parallel coplanar conducting eleof substantially rectangular cross-section; a first accelerating electrode included in said electron gun and having a slot bounded by a pair of parallel portions extending toward said cathode and registering with said beam; a first control grid spaced from said first accelerating electrode by a distance greater than the smallest transverse dimension of said slot and including a plurality of substantially parallel coplanar conducting elements disposed across the path of said beam to define a plurality of continuous transverse interstices across the entire width of said first grid; a focusing electrode disposed about said first grid and having a transverse opening in register with said beam adjacent each side of said first grid; 9. second accelerating electrode having a slot registering with said beam; a second control grid spaced from said second accelerating electrode by a distance greater-than the smallest transverse dimension of the slot of said second accelerating electrode and including a plurality of substantially parallel" conducting elements disposed across said path; and an anode.

ROBERT ADLER.

REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the file of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS Certificate of Correction Patent No. 2,511,143 June 13, 1950 7 ROBERT ADLER a It is hereby certified that errors appear in the printed specification of the above numbered patent requiring correction as follows: 1

Column 1, line 17, for the Word As read An; column 5, line 19, for position read perveance; line 18, for portion read portions;

and that the said Letters Patent should he read with these corrections therein that the same may conform to the record of the case in the Patent Ofiice. Signed and sealed this 12th day of September, A. D. 1950.

THOMAS MURPHY,

Assistant Udflzmz'ssz'oner of Patents.

Certificate of Correction Patent No. 2,511,143 June 13, 1950 V ROBERT ADLER It is hereby certified that errors appear in the printed specification of the above numbered patent requiring correction as follows:

Column 1, line 17, for the word As read An; column 5, line 19, for position read perveance; line 48, for portion read portions;

and that the saidLetters Patent should he read with these corrections therein that the same may conform to the record of the case in the Patent Office.

S1gned and sealed this 12th day of September, A. 1950.

' 'rriomAsr-flxiimrnr,

Assistant Ubinmz'ssioner of Patents. 

